Date of Award
12-10-2026
Document Type
Dissertation
Degree Name
Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.)
School Name
Annsley Frazier Thornton School of Education
Department
Education
Major Advisor
Grant Smith, PhD
Second Advisor
Francis E. Raymond, PhD
Third Advisor
Elizabeth Todd Byron, PhD
Abstract
This dissertation examined relationships between digital capital, digital citizenship, and potential for digital agency among undergraduates in introductory and senior-year community-engaged learning (CEL) courses at a small, private Midwestern university. Extensive research privileges technological access and skills over civic and agentic outcomes. This study responds to that gap by drawing upon critical digital literacy and critical service-learning to investigate students' digital resources, civic practices, and curricular opportunities for engagement. A three-phase mixed-methods design integrated survey responses (N = 78), a seven-student focus group, and review of CEL course materials. The adapted survey combined elements of the Digital Capital Index and Revised Digital Citizenship Scale across five domains: digital access, digital competence, networking agency, internet political action, and critical perspectives. Descriptive, correlational, reliability, and cohort analyses indicated widespread access and relatively high self-reported competence but comparatively limited online political action. Associations varied across domains, and seniors showed no consistent advantage over introductory students. Independently analyzed focus group data highlighted uneven technological preparation, difficulties evaluating online information, civic responsibility, and limits of self-reported skills assessments. Document analysis identified curricular opportunities for information fluency, critical reflection, and community participation, but less explicit attention to digitally mediated civic action. Integrating these sources distinguished reported competencies and civic orientations from curricular expectations. Findings neither establish developmental effects of CEL nor demonstrate conversion of digital resources into offline benefits. The study underscores the need for further survey validation and context-sensitive examination of how digital resources and civic participation relate to students' capacity for digital agency.
Recommended Citation
Thiemann, J Drew, "Beyond Digital Access: Exploring the Third-Level Digital Divide by Assessing Digital Capital and Digital Citizenship in the Socio-Critical Spaces of Community-Engaged Learning" (2026). Graduate Theses, Dissertations, and Capstones. 238.
https://scholarworks.bellarmine.edu/tdc/238
Included in
Civic and Community Engagement Commons, Curriculum and Social Inquiry Commons, Educational Technology Commons, Scholarship of Teaching and Learning Commons, Science and Technology Studies Commons
