Date of Award

10-26-2026

Document Type

Dissertation

Degree Name

Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.)

School Name

Annsley Frazier Thornton School of Education

Department

Education

Major Advisor

Dr. Elizabeth Dinkins

Second Advisor

Dr. James Archibald

Third Advisor

Dr. Emily Dixon-Howard

Abstract

Self-efficacy impacts how undergraduate students build confidence, navigate challenges, and pursue academic and personal goals. This qualitative multiple-case study addressed perceptions of self-efficacy among Black men and women enrolled in undergraduate programs to examine how colleges and universities support self-efficacy development. Guided by Bandura’s self-efficacy and social cognitive theories and critical race theory, the study focused on individual beliefs, lived experiences, relationships, and institutional environments. Participants included 11 undergraduate students from two institutions: five from a public predominantly White institution and six from a private historically Black college or university. Data were collected through semistructured interviews, researcher observations, demographic information, and a self-efficacy questionnaire. Findings revealed men and women demonstrated self-efficacy but differed in developing and sustaining self-belief. Men described self-efficacy through internal standards: personal responsibility, resilience, accountability, and intrinsic motivation. Women identified external and relational influences, including family, peers, mentors, faculty, and environmental experiences. College transitions also shaped self-efficacy as participants navigated independence, academic expectations, identity development, and new social environments. Across institutional contexts, campus programs, culturally affirming spaces, leadership opportunities, faculty engagement, and mentorship strengthened confidence, belonging, and persistence. Findings indicated higher education institutions can support Black undergraduate students’ self-efficacy by cultivating culturally responsive environments, meaningful mentoring relationships, supportive faculty engagement, and accessible leadership and campus engagement opportunities.

Share

COinS